Guide

High impressions, low clicks: how to improve your click-through rate

If Google shows a page thousands of times and hardly anyone clicks, you have a listing problem, not a ranking problem. That's good news, because it's often quicker to fix. Here's how to find those pages and what to change.

In Search Console, list your pages by impressions and look for ones with a low click-through rate for their position. Check the searches behind each page and what Google actually shows. Then rewrite the title and description to match those searches, make sure your product structured data is working, and measure clicks for a few weeks before and after.

What click-through rate means

Click-through rate, or CTR, is the share of people who saw your page in Google and clicked it. Search Console works it out as clicks divided by impressions. An impression is counted when your page appears in someone’s results.

So a page with 4,000 impressions and 40 clicks has a CTR of 1%. If you could get that to 2% without changing its ranking, you’d double the visits from that page.

That’s why “high impressions, low clicks” is worth your attention. Google already shows the page. People are already searching for it. Something in the listing, or around it, is putting them off.

How to find high-impression, low-CTR pages

You’ll need Google Search Console connected to your store. If you haven’t done that, see how to add your Shopify store to Google Search Console.

  1. Open Search Console and go to Performance, then Search results.
  2. Set the date range to the last 3 months, so you’re not misled by a single busy week.
  3. At the top, tick all four boxes: Total clicks, Total impressions, Average CTR and Average position.
  4. Open the Pages tab and sort by Impressions, highest first.
  5. Work down the list. Note pages with lots of impressions and a CTR that’s low compared with your other pages at a similar position.
  6. Click one of those pages, then open the Queries tab to see the searches it appears for.

Comparing by position matters. A page at position 15 will almost always have a low CTR, because few people look at page two. A page at position 4 with the same CTR has a much bigger listing problem. A simple way to judge is to compare each page with others on your site at a similar average position.

Average position is an average across every search a page appears for. A page at “9” might be 3rd for a small search and 25th for a big one. The Queries tab shows you which is which, and it often explains a low CTR on its own.

What’s a typical CTR by position?

These are rough estimates from a typical click-rate curve, the same one our page two calculator uses. Real figures swing a lot with the kind of search, your brand, and what else Google shows, so use them as a sense check, not a target.

Average positionTypical CTR (estimate)
1about 25 to 30%
2about 15%
3about 10%
4 to 5about 5 to 7%
6 to 10about 2 to 4%
11 to 20 (page two)about 1% or less

If a page sits well below the figure for its position, the listing is the likely problem. If it’s in line but the page is at position 9 or 14, the bigger win is moving it up.

Why CTR is low: the five usual causes

1. The page doesn’t rank high enough. Most clicks go to the top few results. If your page sits at the bottom of page one or on page two, CTR will be low however good the listing is. In that case the job is to improve the ranking, as covered in stuck on page 2 of Google. A sharper listing still helps, but it won’t do it all.

2. The listing doesn’t match the search. Look at the main searches in the Queries tab, then read your title and description. If people search “waxed canvas apron” and your title says “Apron 01”, they can’t tell your page is what they want. This is the most common cause, and the easiest to fix.

3. Google has rewritten your title or snippet. Google creates title links and snippets from several sources and may not use yours. Search for the page’s main query yourself and see what Google shows. If it’s a fallback from your page, such as a size chart, a cookie notice or a line about delivery, that will cost clicks.

4. Other things on the results page take the attention. Ads, shopping results, images, videos, “People also ask” boxes and AI answers can all sit above or around your result. Your page might be “position 3” and still appear well down the screen. You can’t remove these, but you can check them, and sometimes target a more specific search instead.

5. Two of your own pages split the clicks. If a product and its collection both appear for the same search, Google may switch between them, and each gets a lower position and fewer clicks. In the Queries tab, click the search and open the Pages tab. If two of your pages show, decide which should win and give the other a different focus.

Search Console data is grouped and rounded, and some searches are hidden for privacy. Small pages with a few dozen impressions can swing wildly. Focus on pages with enough impressions to give steady figures.

How to fix your title and description

Once you know the searches behind a page, rewrite its listing around them.

  • Start the title with the words from the main search, written naturally.
  • Add one detail that makes someone choose you: material, size, where it’s made, a set of four.
  • Keep the title within about 600 pixels so the important part isn’t cut. See title tag length.
  • Write a description that answers the search in the first 120 characters or so, with real details. See meta description length.
  • Make sure the title and the main heading on the page agree. A big mismatch is one reason Google rewrites titles.
  • Don’t promise anything the page doesn’t deliver.

Here’s an invented example from Harbour Supply. The page was getting plenty of impressions for “linen tea towels” but few clicks:

Before

H
Harbour Supply
harboursupply.co.uk › collections › kitchen
Kitchen | Harbour Supply
Size guide: Small 40 x 60cm, Medium 50 x 70cm, Large 60 x 80cm. Please allow 3 to 5 working days for delivery.

After

H
Harbour Supply
harboursupply.co.uk › collections › kitchen
Linen Tea Towels and Kitchen Textiles | Harbour Supply
Stonewashed linen tea towels, aprons and napkins in 9 colours. Soft from the first use, quick to dry and made to last. Free UK delivery over £50.

The “before” title says nothing about tea towels, and the description is a size chart that Shopify took from the start of the collection description. The “after” uses the search words, says what’s on the page and gives a reason to click. To make the change in Shopify, see how to edit your meta title and description, and try the wording first in the SERP preview.

Use structured data for richer results

Structured data is code that tells Google facts about a page in a fixed format. For products, it can let Google show extra details in your result, such as price, whether it’s in stock, and review stars. Google calls these product snippets. A result with a price and a star rating usually stands out more than plain text.

On Shopify, you don’t normally add this yourself:

  • Price and availability usually come from your theme. Many current Shopify themes add basic product structured data automatically.
  • Review stars usually come from a reviews app that adds rating data to your product pages. Check the app’s settings to make sure this is switched on.
  • To check it works, paste a product URL into Google’s Rich Results Test. In Search Console, look for the Product snippets and Merchant listings reports under the enhancements or shopping section.

Two things to keep in mind. First, Google doesn’t guarantee rich results, even when the markup is correct. Second, if the reports show errors, fix them in the theme or app that adds the data, rather than adding a second copy of the same markup. Two conflicting sets can cause more problems than they solve.

Win more space on the results page

Your blue link isn’t the only way to be seen. Some features sit above or beside the normal results, and a page that appears in them often gets more clicks than its position suggests.

  • Featured snippets and “People also ask”. Google pulls short answers from pages that answer a question clearly. On blog posts and guides, put a direct two or three sentence answer under a heading that matches the question.
  • Images. Good product photos with descriptive file names and alt text can appear in image results and image packs.
  • Free shopping listings. Products from the Google & YouTube app in Shopify can show in Google’s shopping results, separate from your normal ranking.
  • Clear, short URLs. Google shows the address as a breadcrumb. “/collections/linen-tea-towels” tells people more than “/collections/kitchen-2”. Change handles with care, and keep the redirect Shopify offers when you do.

Measure the change properly

A new listing isn’t seen straight away. Google has to crawl the page again first, which can take a few days to a few weeks. You can ask for an important page to be re-crawled with the URL Inspection tool in Search Console.

  1. Write down the date you changed the listing, and the old title and description.
  2. Wait until Google is showing the new version. Search for the page to check.
  3. In the Performance report, filter to that page and use the Compare option in the date filter to set the weeks after the change against the same number of weeks before.
  4. Look at clicks and CTR together, and check average position too. If position also moved, part of the change may be down to ranking rather than the listing.
  5. Allow for seasons. A gift shop’s December figures aren’t a fair test of a November change.

Change one thing at a time where you can. If clicks drop, you’ll know what to undo. Serpanda handles this for Shopify stores: it finds pages with high impressions and low clicks from your Search Console data, suggests listings from the real searches, keeps the original so you can undo any change, and compares clicks for up to four weeks after with the four weeks before.

Questions

What is a good click-through rate for SEO?

There’s no single good number. As a rough guide, the top result often gets around a quarter of clicks and positions 6 to 10 get a few percent each, but it depends heavily on the type of search and what else Google shows. Compare a page with your own pages at similar positions, and with its own past figures, rather than with a general benchmark.

Why do I have high impressions but low clicks?

The most common reasons are that the page ranks low on page one or on page two, the listing doesn’t match what people searched for, Google has rewritten your title or snippet, ads, images and other features push your result down the page, or two of your own pages are splitting the clicks.

Does click-through rate affect rankings?

Google doesn’t list click-through rate as a ranking factor, and SEOs still argue about how much clicks feed into rankings. Either way, treat CTR as a measure of how well your listing works. More clicks from the same impressions means more visits, whatever happens to rankings.

How long before I see a change in click-through rate?

Google needs to re-crawl the page first, which can take a few days to a few weeks. Then give it at least two to four weeks of data, and compare with the same length of time before the change.

Will structured data improve my click-through rate?

It can make your result more informative, for example by showing price, stock or review stars. But Google doesn’t guarantee to show rich results, even with correct markup, so treat it as a bonus rather than a fix.

Sources

Stuck on page two?

Serpanda finds your Shopify pages at positions 8 to 20 and helps you fix their Google listings.

Join the waitlist